Contact not being assigned when created

I have an automation that’s part of an inqurity form, and in that automation I’m creating a contact from the name and email fields. I also am assigning that contact to a member of the team. I went to test the form and found that a contact is being created successfully, but not being assigned to anyone.

My Question is, is there an issue with the automation or am I incorrectly assigning the contact? Here are some screenshots of my automation and the results from the contact list.

Hi @Project13,

Have you checked the workflow log for errors? Understand your workflow details page

The create date from the highlighted contact is not from today. If the contact existed before the workflow ran, the create record action (including the assignment) fails as HubSpot cannot create a duplicate. (HubSpot will not update an existing record as part of that action.)

If you test with a net new contact, it should work. Could you test that?

Best regards

I have not, but that puts me in a good direction to look, thanks! Let me see where that takes me and I’ll be able to report back with more info.

I went through those docs and understand things a bit better. You did also happen to answer a question why the contact wasn’t showing the date I expected.

I was able to find an error related to this automation from the Workflows screen that reads, “Unable to create contact because an existing record shares a value that must be unique.” Is this because I’m adding a redundent step to the work flow that doesn’t really need to be there (creating a contact that will already created by a form submission)? Or is it because I need to manage the setting described in this post?

@Project13 you have now added the context to this thread that you didn’t want the form submission to create an additional contact – you just wanted the submitting contact to be created. In that case, the “Create record” action is not required and HubSpot will take care of contact creation automatically as long as you have the “Email” field on the form.

Within this regular contact creation from forms, HubSpot automatically deduplicates by email: Deduplicate records in HubSpot

This means that a contact will be created new if the email address does not yet exist. If it does exist, HubSpot will update the contact record with the matching email address.

The error you’re seeing really comes from the (yes, redundant) step you have added. By this point, the form submission has already created or updated the contact record. In your case, the contact was created a few days ago and the most recent form submission will have updated them accordingly.

Now, the “Create record” workflow action is attempting to create another record with the same email address. This action is “dumb” in that way that it will not try to update, just create. That however violates HubSpot’s deduplication rules: There cannot be two contact records with the same email address.

That’s why the action fails: HubSpot can’t execute it while at the same time making sure that the email address fields on the existing and new contact records are unique.

Generally, you would only use the “Create record” action in a form submission scenario when the submitting contact also wants to register a +1 for an event, for example. The submitting contact would be updated automatically through the form, the “Create record” workflow action could create the record for the +1.

Hope this explains things and makes it more clear. If it does, consider marking my reply as an accepted solution, I’d appreciate it!

Hi @Project13

Why are you creating a contact via workflow after a form submission?
The form submission itself will create a new contact - your only action should be the assigment.

Frank

I suppose I didn’t know that the form created the contact without me needing to handle that through an automation. I’m pretty new to HubSpot and so I’m still learning the ins and outs of the software.

Hi @Project13,

use the “Rotate record to owner” step to assign the owner, IF you just want for the one form.

Otherwise I would recommend creating a workflow > add all important forms in trigger > use round robin (if multiple team members) or assign to a specific user to save you time and make you task easier.

And, as @karstenkoehler mentioned, you can’t assign an owner to existing contacts. This will be the only work post setup new submission if you setup for specfic form.

If you want enroll existing contact too, go with workflow option which is best for you!

Did this help? Mark it as the solution to help others too.Thank you,HARSHAD PATELFractional GTM & HubSpot ConsultantGet free advice or start your free trial today at Consultey.com

This did it! Thank you so much. I will look into the other solution you offered to see if that is a better way to do things.