Been a minute on this thread…
Came across this recently. I’ve been loosely associated with Service CSAT/CSET/NPS efforts a few times throughout my career but never in a capacity to dig through results and question viability. With most of those organizations they either didn’t have the bandwidth or weren’t sophisticated enough to put in place ops to follow up with all detractors or those that didn’t leave comments…
Recently we’ve built a feedback/ticketing system for NPS (to support testimonials, reviews, and the marketing possibilities) and found that a decent number of NPS Detractors were actually triggered by “erroneous feedback clicks”.. likely email security crawlers/settings that accidentally registered feedback.. It wasn’t just 0’s or 1’s but some 4’s, 5’s, and 6’s as well.
We haven’t fully explored if this applies to other Passives/Promoters that didn’t provide feedback—however the unfortunate aspect is that it throws the rest of the response data set into question.
Curious if anyone has more experience/feedback or performed additional tests and can add some insight?