HubSpot Forms Randomly Stopping Contact Submissions on My Website Without Generating Errors

I am experiencing a persistent issue with HubSpot forms on my website, and I have been unable to determine the root cause despite extensive testing. The forms are embedded across several landing pages and are used for collecting inquiries, consultation requests, and newsletter subscriptions. For some visitors, submissions are processed normally and contacts appear in HubSpot almost instantly. However, other users complete the form successfully but their information never reaches the CRM. The problem occurs intermittently and does not generate any obvious error messages on the frontend.

What makes this issue particularly confusing is that users generally receive the normal submission confirmation message after clicking the submit button. From their perspective, the form appears to work correctly and the process seems complete. However, when I check the contact database, some submissions are missing entirely and no new contact record is created. In certain cases, I can see page visits and user activity tracking within HubSpot, but the associated form submission is absent. This creates uncertainty because there is no clear indication that a failure has occurred.

I initially suspected validation conflicts or browser-specific compatibility issues, so I tested the forms across multiple devices and browsers. The behavior was observed on Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and mobile browsers, although it does not happen consistently enough to identify a specific environment as the cause. I also reviewed custom JavaScript running on the website to determine whether any scripts might be interfering with the form submission process. Despite temporarily disabling several custom features, the issue continued appearing at random intervals. Because of this, I have not been able to isolate the problem to a particular script or browser.

Another detail I noticed is that the missing submissions seem to occur more frequently during periods of higher website traffic. When multiple users are interacting with forms simultaneously, there appears to be a greater chance that some submissions never reach HubSpot. I reviewed website server logs and did not find signs of failed requests, timeouts, or resource limitations during these periods. The website itself remains responsive and other features continue functioning normally. This makes me wonder whether the issue could be related to how form requests are processed or synchronized with HubSpot under load.

To troubleshoot further, I checked tracking code implementation, cookie consent settings, spam filtering rules, and form automation workflows. I also created duplicate forms for testing purposes and compared the results between different landing pages. Unfortunately, the same intermittent behavior continues regardless of which form is being used. Some submissions are recorded perfectly while others seem to disappear without any trace. Since there are no obvious errors in the browser console or HubSpot activity logs, identifying the exact failure point has been extremely challenging.

I would appreciate guidance from anyone who has encountered similar issues with HubSpot forms or contact synchronization. I am trying to determine whether this behavior is commonly associated with tracking conflicts, embedded form configurations, browser privacy settings, automation workflows, or another technical factor. My goal is to ensure that every valid submission is captured reliably without losing potential leads. If anyone has experience diagnosing intermittent form submission failures where users receive confirmation messages but contacts are not created, I would be grateful for any recommendations on where to focus my investigation next. Sorry for long post!

Hey @BStokes2 and Happy Monday!

Thanks for reaching out to the HubSpot Community and for sharing what you already tried!

Are your pages hosted on HubSpot or externally, please?

You might want to take a look at these similar threads that might help:

Now, let’s consult our Top Experts: Hi @TomM2, @trevordjones and @Anton do you have suggestions to help @BStokes2, please?

Thanks so much and have a lovely day!
Bérangère

Thanks for the response and for sharing those related discussions. The forms are embedded on externally hosted pages rather than pages hosted directly on HubSpot, which is one reason I’ve been wondering whether there could be an issue somewhere between the embedded form submission process and contact creation within the CRM.

I’ve already reviewed tracking code placement, consent settings, custom scripts, and form configurations, but the intermittent nature of the problem has made it difficult to pinpoint the exact cause. What’s particularly confusing is that users receive the normal success message, yet some submissions never appear as contacts and leave very little evidence behind for troubleshooting.

I’ll go through the threads you linked to see if there are any common patterns that match what I’m experiencing. In the meantime, I’m interested to hear whether the experts have seen cases where embedded forms on external websites successfully acknowledge submissions but occasionally fail to create contact records, especially during periods of increased traffic. Thanks again for escalating the question and for any additional insights the community can provide.

Hey @BStokes2, thanks for sharing the additional information!

You might want to check out these resources too:

Also, here are a few things to double-check:

  • You mentioned that you’ve reviewed your custom JavaScript and turned off some features. Just to double-check, did you happen to have any redirect logic running in onFormSubmit or onBeforeFormSubmit?

  • If you’re self-hosting the js.hsforms.net script, note that this isn’t supported. HubSpot regularly updates this script for security and anti-spam reasons, a local copy can go out of date and may result in dropped submissions.

  • If you’ve embedded the same form more than once on a page, remember to assign a unique formInstanceId to each. Without this, submissions might conflict.

I’d love to hear from our Top Experts: Hi @evaldas, @zach_threadint and @SteveHTM do you have any insights to share with @BStokes2, please?

Thanks so much and enjoy the weekend!
Bérangère

This post was created with the assistance of AI tools

Hey @BStokes2 ,

Might not have a full answer, but jumping in to address one of the points you mentioned:

websites successfully acknowledge submissions but occasionally fail to create contact records

In the form settings, there is a toggle that determines whether a form submission should create a new contact. If this is turned off, there is a chance that some users who would be submitting a form on a shared device would override an existing contact instead of creating a new record.

Also, instead of looking purely at contact records, I would also look directly at the form submissions. This would be the more accurate source of truth on whether the submissions are recorded in your portal (as opposed to looking at contact records).

If HubSpot forms stop submitting contacts without showing errors, check browser console logs, form embed scripts, third-party plugins, and tracking blockers. Also review HubSpot form settings, duplicate contact rules, and submission notifications. Testing in incognito mode can help identify conflicts.