Hi,
When a contact has retired or left their company and leaves a replacement email address in an Out of Office email, what’s best practice for adding (or not adding) that replacement email in your database?
I’ve thought of three ideas that I keep going back and forth on, and would love some advice (or if there are different ideas!). Here’s what I’ve been debating:
- Should I make a new contact record for the replacement (but then they wouldn’t have opted into receiving marketing emails from your company)?
- Should I make a Note in the old contact’s record with the new information (but that could cause unwanted clutter in your database)?
- Or should I delete the old contact and not worry about adding the replacement’s info (but maybe the company these contacts are from is an important one to work with and you might loose your new way “in”)?
Thank you!
Hi @lstemley,
Interesting questions…
My opinions would be as follows:
- Should I make a new contact record for the replacement?
No, probably not. As you note: they haven’t opted in. IMHO personal outreach is always the best option, so perhaps a quick, direct email saying “I’ve previously been dealing with X [+context and history]… I’ve just got an email saying he’s left Company name - is this something you’re interested in picking up on?”
If they reply positively, create the contact and move forward. If you don’t get a response, maybe try once more or give up!?
- Should I make a Note in the old contact’s record with the new information?
I generally retain old contacts in my database, but opt them out of email and set lifecycle stage to a custom value “Left company”. If they later crop up again at a new company, I’ll pin a note to the top of their file with a hyperlink to their previous HS Contact record and vice versa, which allows me to jump to any previous correspondence. No harm in pinning a note saying “left company, replaced by Joe Bloggs - joe@companyname.com”…
- Or should I delete the old contact and not worry about adding the replacement’s info (but maybe the company these contacts are from is an important one to work with and you might loose your new way “in”)?
This is probably the hardest bit - you don’t want to lose your “in” at the previous company. Per my first response, I think personal outreach is the best option, here. Could always temporarily add the new contact to your CRM, design a short sequence and, if there’s no response during the sequence, have the last email state that you’ll remove their data from your system.
Hi @AdamLPW ,
A simple outreach does sound like a good idea, though I think I might try it through my own email. Thanks for your thoughts!
This is an older thread, but it’s a problem I still see regularly in email marketing and HubSpot data.
I think the best practice is to treat the original contact and the replacement as two different people rather than changing the email address on the existing contact.
If an auto-reply says that John has left and Jane is the new contact, I would generally:
-
Keep John’s contact record so you preserve the history.
-
Mark John as no longer with the company and prevent future marketing emails.
-
Create Jane as a new contact if she doesn’t already exist.
-
Associate Jane with the same company and, where appropriate, the relevant deals and owner.
-
Record where the replacement information came from so there is an audit trail.
-
Update marketing contact status for all contacts.
The difficult part is that doing all of this manually every time one of these replies comes in is easy to miss and doesn’t scale.
I ran into this enough that I built ContactContinuity to handle this specific issue. It identifies these types of contact-change replies and “I’ve left the company” emails, recommends the appropriate HubSpot changes, and lets someone approve them before anything is updated.